You are here:

Fish/Water changes causes fish to freak out


Hello and thank you for your help. I have a 55 gallon tank with 5 goldfish and 2 sucker fish. We recently moved to a new city, since the move everytime I change the water the fish seem to"freak" out. The swim at a 45 degree angle with no purpose. The usually will remain at the top and will sometimes jump out of the water hitting the lid. Then they fall to bottom and lay there for several minutes. After that will continue doing the above scenario. I have had one goldfish die and one sucker fish also. The rest seem to recover after a awhile. I do have a water softner and thought that maybe this was the problem, I also had one in the old house but this never happened, so I used an outside slickest this time. The results were the same. I don't know why this continues to happen as I am not doing anything different from what I used to in the old house. Can you please help?

This is a textbook case of Cl-/Br-/I- Poisoning. Many cities put these ions into the water for taste and sanitation purposes, but they wreak havoc on fish and aquatic life. Your fish recover because the ions eventually diffuse into the air.
"Dechlorinator" is commonly available in pet stores. Just use that regularly with waterchanges and you should be fine.
Your other option is to get a clean 50 gallon drum (plastic)  and store water in there 72 hours prior to a water change with aeration. These will both remove the ions, some people even do both simultaneously.


All Answers

Answers by Expert:

Ask Experts




I can answer questions relating to the scientific aspect of the hobby (fish ecology, biology, genetics, etc. ), aquacultural and breeding aspects, and have experience with nearly all "brackish" fish in the trade. I also have lots of experience breeding fish, like angelfish, tetras, cichlids, and various livebearers. I also have lots of experience with many freshwater fish, especially "monster" fish, like stingrays, arowana and Saratoga, cichlids, catfish, etc. Please ask questions about anything except for true saltwater (reef) tanks.


Too much to fully list, but I will never have never enough to satisfy myself.

River Watch of Colorado Monster Fish Keepers USA Canoe/Kayak

Student, but I've been involved in many projects involving aquaculture and fish biology. I'm currently helping design a massive stream improvement project on the St. Vrain river. I am studying fisheries ecology, techniques, hatcheries, and management practices for north american freshwater systems.

©2017 All rights reserved.