Food Science/egg..is it a meat?

Advertisement


Dan wrote at 2009-09-06 20:35:33
Hello,

I believe this question is more complicated than it seems. If meat is considered to be the flesh of an animal, eggs very well may be considered meat as the egg is an animal cell. In this way, the argument that eggs and milk are similar in that they both give sustenance to young isn't really accurate, because milk is not cellular.



Is caviar meat? Is blood? We often feel that meat must be muscle. What about animal eyes, or even brain? It is my opinion that an egg must be considered meat, even when unfertilized. It seems a silly distinction that as soon as the egg is fertilized it would then be meat, only one or two cell divisions later.


Michael Polidori wrote at 2014-01-31 18:14:05
Hi Dan,

I have to disagree with most of your post.



If by egg you actually mean the ovarian egg or the egg of a hen, that is certainly not meat. The ovarian egg or unfertilized hen's egg cannot replicate and has only half the DNA necessary to create a living organism.



Milk and egg yolk are similar in providing nutrition to offspring. Neither are cellular.



Caviar is meat in the same sense that egg is and isn't  considered meat, according to the state of fertilization and the purposes for which you are trying to determine the meat status.



In your second sentence you state an egg is an animal cell, singular. So how could it be considered "a silly distinction that as soon as the egg is fertilized it would then be meat"?


Food Science

All Answers


Answers by Expert:


Ask Experts

Volunteer


Michael Polidori

Expertise

I can answer questions about food safety issues and benefits vs risks issues related to the growing, environmental effects and health effects of conventional, organic and gene altered food (GE GMO genetically engineered), both plants and animals. I can answer questions related to the cause and treatment of nutritionally related disease (including immune related diseases) and nutritional problems related to healing physiological or nutritional injuries.

Experience

I have been studying food growing methods, regulatory rules and organic/conventional/biotechnological methods of producing foods since 1998. I have prepared materials for distribution concerning health safety issues, lack of regulation, environmental dangers and industry sponsored research of genetically engineered plants and animals. I have also created similar materials promoting the benefits of organic agriculture for not only direct health benefits but for dramatic reductions in pollution, indirectly benefitting our health. I have prepared research materials for and participated in Public Television talk and radio shows regarding the issues surrounding genetic engineering and organic foods and debated in college forums with mainstream scientific experts about the safety & regulatory issues of gene altered foods. 2000-2002 I managed booths at major North Carolina events interfacing with the public (including farmers) on organic vs GMO benefits and dangers. I understand regulatory practices, shortcomings & revolving jobs doors of the FDA, USDA and EPA and the industries they regulate. I have been involved in nutrition, health care, prescription drug, vaccine, disease, immune and wellness issues since 1997 reading and writing on the internet and in practical applications with myself, family and friends leading to paths of health, wellness and fitness.

Organizations
North Carolina Citizens For Safe Food, Public Citizen, Organic Consumers Association, Union of Concerned Scientists, Environmental Working Group, PSRAST.

Education/Credentials
No Degree, but some college in the sciences (Biology, Chemistry, Calculus, Astronomy and Physics). I have also taken several courses in Logic and Philosophy. I am involved in extensive research using mainstream websites (many of which I am on mailing lists for) such as - peer-reviewed publications (The Lancet, New England Journal of Medicine, others), PubMed database of research studies, National Institutes of Health, FDA, USDA, EPA, University Research libraries, hospital databases (John Hopkins, Mayo Clinic, Cleveland Clinic, others). I also regulary contact/correspond-with manufacturers/suppliers of food products, pharmaceuticals (including vaccines) and supplements with questions, recommendations, criticisms and complements. Every week, I learn something new!

©2016 About.com. All rights reserved.