You are here:

French Horn/Holton H378 ad and bore size questions

Advertisement


Question
I was a good intermediate player in college, and am looking to get back into playing after about 17 years.  I miss it desperately (I do lip slurs on my old mouthpiece as I drive to and from work.  Is that sad?  lol). and hope to join a local community orchestra when I can get a horn and get back into presentable shape.  My dad was an instrumental music teacher (his main instrument was trumpet) and was always able to get a good district double horn for me, so I've never owned or searched for my own horn.

My first question is basically your opinion on an ad. I can't afford one right now, but based on your recommendation of Holton H378 in other posts, is this a good price for this horn?

http://www.hornsociety.org/free-classifieds/5-full-double/4159-holton

It looks a bit cosmetically beat up, but it seems a good deal compared to other listings I've seen on eBay, Craigslist, etc for that model. Would this be a horn that I should jump on or be leery of?

My second question is in regard to horn throat size. I see that you usually recommend medium-throat horns. I tested a horn once in college in which I could get a very big sound without much resistance. I could also hit 2 notes higher on it (probably a high Bb or C, but I don't remember exactly) than on the school horn. We were stupid and didn't buy it.  Based on how easily I remember putting air through it, I would guess that it was a large throat horn. Would you agree based on that description?  But I've also read that typically it's harder to hit high notes on large-throat horns, so I'm not sure it was one. It might have just been a better built horn that what I was used to.

Typically I enjoy playing higher than lower, so would you recommend a medium-throat horn for easier accuracy, or a larger throat horn that I could put a lot of air through?  Again, main playing would be in the community orchestra, church band, maybe random quartets or quintets, etc.  I know it's tough to judge without hearing me (or the me I was and hopefully will be again), but I'd appreciate your opinion.  Thank you!

Answer
Hi, as long as you don't mind the slightly cosmetically challenged state it looks like a very good deal.

I'd say for someone re-starting after a long layoff, a medium-bore horn probably is the best idea, and yes, I'm a fan of the 378 for anyone on a limited budget. They generally play all the notes nicely in tune and make a very nice sound. If you're more likely to play high than low, you'll definitely find it easier to be accurate and centre notes on a 378 compared to, let's say, a 179 or a Conn 8D

I'd give it a try...

AJ

French Horn

All Answers


Answers by Expert:


Ask Experts

Volunteer


Alan Jones

Expertise

Can answer just about anything on playing the horn, repertoire, buying instruments, repairs, care and maintenance

Experience

25 years of professional playing and teaching in the UK

Education/Credentials
GRSM (Hons), LRAM, ARCM

©2016 About.com. All rights reserved.