General Writing and Grammar Help/Is it,,,?


Hello there

Hope you are fine!

I have a question. Is the following sentence correct? And if not, please tell me why it is not.

"Who did you say that took the book?"

I look forward to hearing from you.

Thank you a lot
Best to you

Hi Hame!

Sorry for the very late reply!

It is incorrect by itself.  You could modify it slightly to make it correct:

"Who did you say IT WAS that took the book?"

But going this far is unnecessary.  You could also simplify it this way:

"Who did you say took the book?"

And it would mean virtually the same thing.

Hope that helps!

General Writing and Grammar Help

All Answers

Answers by Expert:

Ask Experts




Anything to do with word usage and/or grammar, plus the fundamentals on almost any type of writing (especially creative writing, such as poetry, short stories, movie/dramatic scripts, etc.)


Majored in English literature in college; have published short stories and poems, currently teaching English as a second language to foreigners

As mentioned above, a bachelor's in English Literature and also a CELTA certification which enables me to teach English as a second language to foreigners.

Awards and Honors
Editor's Choice for a national poetry contest. 2nd prize for a short story in a city-wide short story contest.

©2017 All rights reserved.