You are here:

Geology/Climate conditions

Advertisement


Question
QUESTION: I am researching the claims of the finding of Noah's ark. My question is: Would the climate condtions on Mt. Ararat at the altitude of 13,000 feet where the discovery was supposedly made have existed 5,000 years ago, before the ark was built? Or can there be extreme climate changes in mountainous high altitudes over an extended period of time? In other words, could there have been a time in the distant past when the conditions at that height were that of warmer temperatures, allowing the growth of tree stands where wood could have been harvested on site to make wooden structures?

This relates to the claims that the wood structure(s) found on Mt. Ararat was a monastery or were shrines built by ancient monks or pens built by animal herders using indigenous wood at that altitude.

Thank you very much for your time.

ANSWER: My answer is a bit hypothetic as I am not aware of the geography of  the area as I have never visited the sites you have mentioned.

There are 2-3 scientific principles which are also universal:

(1) with increase in latitude the climate becomes cooler ( can be under permanent snow as well).
(2) with increase of elevation the climate becomes cooler ( can be under permanent snow as well).
(3)The global wind circulation and the spin and earth's rotation along its orbit also impacts climate at  a place.

imagine a condition that suddenly if the global pattern of wind circulation shifts in such a way (for what ever reasons)  that the monsoon too shifts away from the Indian sub-continent - In this situation what would be the conditions at high Himalayan region which is always shrouded by snow and ice.

We have examples of Mohan-jodaro civilisation etc. which had highly evolved irrigation network indicating high rain fall in and surrounding areas some 3 to 4 thousand years back,  today they lie as ruins amidst desert conditions.

You  have a valid question and you have to hunt for answers in geological-geographical and anthropological literatures/records  and on site.

I have only tried to exemplify situations that my give you ideas to think.
Thanks



---------- FOLLOW-UP ----------

QUESTION: Your answer didn't really satisfy my question. I'll rephrase. Given your area of expertise, what, in your opinion, are the chances that condtions, such as the kind of permanent snow and ice that exist at the altitude of 13,000 feet on Mt Ararat, or any high mountain, would be completely different 5,000 years ago?

Answer
I have no more than what I have already said, for more specific answers pl. contact laboratories engaged in glacial studies of the past.

I can only add that the planet has experienced warm climate since 11000 or 10500 years BP as per Quaternary records (Post Pleistocene-Holocene climate changes.

Also climatic changes are never straight line changes they may have climatic aberrations or extreme short/long period events. 5000 years ago what was the ice-snow cover records (glacial-interglacial)  on Mt. Ararta and similar peaks is a question you need to address through proxies.
All the best
thanks

Geology

All Answers


Answers by Expert:


Ask Experts

Volunteer


N.K.Agarwal

Expertise

Would be happy to answer : General Geology, Engineering Geology, Economic Geology, Geomorphology, Geoenvironment, Tectonics, Natural Resources inclusive of Rocks & Minerals, Exploration, Science Policy etc.

Experience

Geological-Geotechnical Solutions and professional advice. I have over 34 years of professional experience of working as a geologist in diverse mountainous terrain. I have professional skills for planning. programming, executing and monitoring of : (1) Engineering Geological investigations in Hydropower and Developmental projects, (2) Landslide and Disaster Management etc. (3) Natural Resource Management and Programming (4) Geological Mapping (5) Geoenvironmental Management (6) Mineral Exploration (7) Water Resources Management, (8) Integrated Watershed Management, (9) Training on - Natural Resource Management, Geoenvironmental Management, Waste Management, Geohazards, Geotechnical Investigations, Data acquisition & interpretations, (10) R&D Initiatives and Societal issues etc.

Organizations
ex-Geological Survey of India. Retired Director now Geo-Consultant and Advisor -HIGEOS India

Publications
Departmental Publications mostly

Education/Credentials
M.Tech.(Applied Geology), University of Roorkee (now IIT Roorkee).

Past/Present Clients
Worked in the Geological Survey of India for aabout 32 years. Presently - GeoConsultant & Advisor - HIGEOS India

©2016 About.com. All rights reserved.