You are here:

Historical/War Reenactment/Is WWII reenacting questionably illegal

Advertisement


Question
As a WWII reenactor, i was wondering, I have read U.S.C. 704, governing ones right to wear a military uniform, and that when done so for theatrical purposes by an actor it is allowed unless it makes the branch of service look bad, and could see this working for Civil War reenactors whose events are for public viewing, but our WWII events are all closed tacticals, where no one but ourselves are present. Where could I find info governing our right as a club to exist, what regulations must be followed to exist as a club. Is a club obligated by law to hold a certain number of public events a year?  Thank you, Jim

Answer
Jim:

  Thing is, with 18 USC 704, as I recall, there also has to be an 'intent' to deceive.   It would be different if you guys were running around claiming to be WWII vets, earned awards, etc.   As far as the law goes, I don't think you are going to have an issue, 'Stolen valor', or otherwise.   

 Regarding your organization, something you might want to consider is making it a 'not for profit' group.   I'm not sure how you do that, but several organizations I've belonged to and worked with have done that and it seems to have worked out well for them.    But,  if you go that route, I think there is something in the fedlaw that says you have to do so much 'for' the public, be it education, open events, etc.   Otherwise, if you are not, (a not for profit etc) there is nothing that I'm aware of that says you have to be 'open' to the public at all.

 Wish I could be more help but this one is sort of outside my area of knowledge, sorry.

Historical/War Reenactment

All Answers


Answers by Expert:


Ask Experts

Volunteer


Jason Grabill

Expertise

Civil War Reenacting, how to start, what to buy, how to find a good unit (Union or Confederate), publications and books to read. Also Medical reenacting; same as above.

Experience

Began reenacting in 1996 with the Stonewall Brigade as an Infantry Reenactor, transistioned to Medical in 2000.

Organizations
Co D 27th Virginia Volunteer Infantry (Stonewall Brigade) CSA
Society of Civil War Surgeons


Publications
Wrote 2 Battlefield Tour Guides for Antietam and Fredericksburg for the US Marine Corps, currently in the Warfighting labratory in Quantico.

Education/Credentials
Extensive study on the arms, equipment and daily life of the Civil War Soldier; have a personal library of over 200 books, and the "Official Records of the War of the Rebellion" on CD. Also have numerous books on Civil War Medicine, including period books. Currently a volunteer at the National Museum of Civil War Medicine in Frederick, Md

Awards and Honors
27th Virginia Infantry "Infantry Rookie of the Year" 1997

©2016 About.com. All rights reserved.