Interspecies Conflict/Close Match ups

Advertisement


Question
following below are some groups of animals with their weight and gender.Lke Cheetah(M 60) means male cheetah weighing 60 Kg. Weights provided would be realistic so there will be no need for scaling up or down any particular animal. In particular group each animal will fight other four. Winning a battle decisively gives 2 points while a close battle will give 1 point to each. Could you please predict result of each match up, group rankings and winners.Please provide details wherever you feel necessary.

1. African Elephant (F 4700) White Rhino (M 4200) Asiatic Elephant (M 4200) Forest Elephant (F 3500) Asiatic Elephant (F 4000)

2. White Rhino (F 1600) Black Rhino (M 1400) Hippo (M 1800)  Gaur (M 1200) Black Rhino (F 1200)

3. Siberian Tiger (M 230) Bengal Tiger (M 220) African Lion (M 200) Asiatic Lion (M 170) Bengal Tigeress (F 180)

4. Jaguar (M 140) Bengal Tiger (F 170) African Lion (F 150) Asiatic Lion (F 140) Sumatran Tiger (M 120)

Answer
Hello Ravi.


Group #1

African Elephant (F 4700) loses to White Rhino (M 4200); very close fight.
African Elephant (F 4700) edges Asiatic Elephant (M 4200); very close fight.
African Elephant (F 4700) defeats Forest Elephant (F 3500); decisive win.
African Elephant (F 4700) defeats Asiatic Elephant (F 4000); close fight.
White Rhino (M 4200) defeats Asiatic Elephant (M 4200); close fight.
White Rhino (M 4200) defeats Forest Elephant (F 3500); decisive win.
White Rhino (M 4200) defeats Asiatic Elephant (F 4000); close fight.
Asiatic Elephant (M 4200) defeats Forest Elephant (F 3500); decisive win.
Asiatic Elephant (M 4200) defeats Asiatic Elephant (F 4000); close fight.
Forest Elephant (F 3500) loses to Asiatic Elephant (F 4000); close fight.

* I favor rhinos over elephants at close weights due to better weapon positioning and lower center of gravity.  Considered testosterone levels and tusk size.  African elephants are typically the most aggressive elephants.

African Elephant (F 4700) - 5 points
White Rhino (M 4200) - 5 points
Asiatic Elephant (M 4200) - 5 points
Forest Elephant (F 3500) - 1 point
Asiatic Elephant (F 4000) - 4 points

Group #2

White Rhino (F 1600) loses to Black Rhino (M 1400); very close fight.
White Rhino (F 1600) defeats Hippo (M 1800); decisive win.
White Rhino (F 1600) defeats Gaur (M 1200); decisive win.
White Rhino (F 1600) defeats Black Rhino (F 1200); decisive win.
Black Rhino (M 1400) defeats Hippo (M 1800); decisive win.
Black Rhino (M 1400) defeats Gaur (M 1200); decisive win.
Black Rhino (M 1400) defeats Black Rhino (F 1200); close fight.
Hippo (M 1800) edges Gaur (M 1200); very close fight.
Hippo (M 1800) loses to Black Rhino (F 1200); close fight.
Gaur (M 1200) loses to Black Rhino (F 1200); decisive loss.

* Hippos aren't as capable on land as rhinos.  I favor a gaur over a hippo at parity, but not if it's only 2/3 the hippo's weight.  Black rhinos tend to be more aggressive than other rhinos.

White Rhino (F 1600) - 7 points
Black Rhino (M 1400) - 5 points
Hippo (M 1800) - 2 points
Gaur (M 12000 - 1 point
Black Rhino (F 1200) - 2 points

Group #3

Siberian Tiger (M 230) edges Bengal Tiger (M 220); close fight.
Siberian Tiger (M 230) edges African Lion (M 200); close fight.
Siberian Tiger (M 230) defeats Asiatic Lion (M 170); decisive win.
Siberian Tiger (M 230) defeats Bengal Tigress (F 180); decisive win.
Bengal Tiger (M 220) edges African Lion (M 200); close fight.
Bengal Tiger (M 220) defeats Asiatic Lion (M 170); decisive win.
Bengal Tiger (M 220) defeats Bengal Tigress (F 180); decisive win.
African Lion (M 200) defeats Asiatic Lion (M 170); decisive win.
African Lion (M 200) defeats Bengal Tigress (F 180); decisive win.
Asiatic Lion (M 170) edges Bengal Tigress (F 180); very close fight.

* I slightly favor lions over tigers at parity because they fight more.  African lions fight more than Asiatic lions.  Testosterone taken into account.

Siberian Tiger (M 230) - 6 points
Bengal Tiger (M 220) - 6 points
African Lion (M 200) - 6 points
Asiatic Lion (M 170) - 1 point
Bengal Tigress (F 180) - 1 point

Group #4

Jaguar (M 140) loses to Bengal Tiger (F 170); reasonably close fight.
Jaguar (M 140) loses to African Lion (F 150); very close fight.
Jaguar (M 140) defeats Asiatic Lion (F 140); close fight.
Jaguar (M 140) defeats Sumatran Tiger (M 120); reasonably close fight.
Bengal Tiger (F 170) defeats African Lion (F 150); close fight.
Bengal Tiger (F 170) defeats Asiatic Lion (F 140); reasonably close fight.
Bengal Tiger (F 170) defeats Sumatran Tiger (M 120); decisive win.
African Lion (F 150) defeats Asiatic Lion (F 140); close fight.
African Lion (F 150) defeats Sumatran Tiger (M 120); decisive win.
Asiatic Lion (F 140) defeats Sumatran Tiger (M 120); close fight.

* I favor jaguars over other big cats at parity due to pound-for-pound strength, bite force, and killing technique (will bite through skull or spine).  Lions and tigers are right behind them, though.

Jaguar (M 140) - 4 points
Bengal Tiger (F 170) - 5 points
African Lion (F 150) - 5 points
Asiatic Lion (F 140) - 4 points
Sumatran Tiger (M 120) - 2 points


Best regards.  

Interspecies Conflict

All Answers


Answers by Expert:


Ask Experts

Volunteer


BK

Expertise

Questions regarding animal conflicts within realistic or unrealistic settings are welcome; my strength lies in medium-to-large species. Small animals (including birds of prey), prehistoric animals, sea creatures, and domestic dog breeds are usually within my scope, but to a lesser degree. I can't confidently answer hypothetical questions about human vs animal, arachnids, insects, or amphibians, but I am willing to field them nonetheless.

Experience

From a young age, I have been interested in animals. Starting with the original Mutual of Omaha's Wild Kingdom and World Book Encyclopedias, I have seen many animal shows and documentaries and have read multiple books on the subject. I have a solid understanding of the physiology of many animals and interspecies conflict in general.

Education/Credentials
Associate degree in unrelated field; biology classes in college.

©2016 About.com. All rights reserved.