You are here:

Islam/Question about hadith. (Bukhari and Muslim)



First of all, when I asked a question previously, you marked it as "homework" question. In reality, it was not a "homework" question.

Anyway, today I am going to ask a very important and serious question. I am NOT a shia or Quran alone Muslim.

I was reading some hadiths of the two collections of Al-bukhari and Muslim and found some weird hadith which CAN Not be justified by ANYONE. I can even provide them in the follow-up question, but I want to know your view of these two collections of hadiths. Majority of Mullahs and scholars consider Al-Bukhari and Muslim to be 100% correct and authentic collection of hadiths. But the problem is not solved here, in fact, the problem is worsened. I am a researcher, and during my research, I found something very contrary to what these mullahs and scholars believe. I found that NOT all hadith of Bukhari and Muslim are 100% correct or authentic. I can give you the source. I am waiting for your answer.

ANSWER: My brother,
I am sorry, I don't remember when did I reject your question. Anyway,, coming to your present question I must apprise you of the fact that whenever you find any "Hadish Sharif" which conflicts or contradicts with Holy Quran then without any hesitation you should come to the conclusion that said "Hadish Sharif" is fake.

---------- FOLLOW-UP ----------

QUESTION: Thanks for your answer. My question is that why do these mullahs and top order "scholars" believe that books like bukhari and muslim are 100% authentic and correct? Can't they see that many hadith are not authentic and even does not make any sense? For example, the hadith of stoning of the she monkey for adultery, etc?

Can I again ask the question which you rejected previously?


My dear brother,
I don't know whom do you call and consider as MUllah and top scholars. However by sporting beard one can not become Mullah or Moulvi.
Please send your question if not already got the answer from other expert(s)


All Answers

Answers by Expert:

Ask Experts


Mufti Md.Zia-ul-Haque,Alim & Advocate


By the Grace of Almighty Allah,being the only person in the world who is qualified Moulvi(Passed the Alim Examination Conducted By Madrasa Education Board) with Degrees in Science and Law I am,MASHALLAH,able to answer any question on Islamic Religion.That apart,I was in charge of Legal,Calcutta Office of Custodian of Enemy,Govt of India and Export Inspection Agency,Calcuuta, Ministry of Commerce,Govt of India from where I have retired on 31.3.2010,It is also therefore possible for me to answer questions on Indian Civil Law and Service Matters. Md.Zia-ul-Haque,B.Sc,LLB,Alim(Cal) Alim & Advocate Md,Zia-ul-Haque,B.Sc, LLB,Alim(Cal) Alim & Advocate


Stated in the above field.

Stated above

1. Quran-o-Hadis-er Aloke Pita-o-Matar Martoba (Bengali) 2. Milad Sharif (Transliterated to Bengali) 3. Shaheed-e-Karbala(Bengali) 4. Hazarat Maula Ali Muishkil Kusha -o- Papi Mabiya -o- Duschoroitro Taslima Nasrin(Bengali) 5. Ahl-e-Bayt Pak (AS) -o- Jahannami Mua'wiyah-o-Yazid (Bengali)

B.Sc, LLB, Alim(Cal)

©2017 All rights reserved.