Jehovah`s Witness/JWs and being prophets


Hello Robert,

I just read your response to my letter to Dee.  

I did not mean to offend you, I am sorry if I did, but your statement to Dee do show that you have an agenda and an ax to grind.  We all have some sort of ax to grind, and from the little I have read of your comments you ax is to discredit JWs, not as outwardly as some but still to discredit us. Other wise your wording would not be as negative as it was. What you wrote in the letter I am replying to definitely shows that you have an ax to grind

I respect your right to say as you feel as we all have that right. I do not want to argue with anyone but I have to take a stand on the false prophet thing.  Unfortunately much of what you said is not correct as you only give partial information.  For example that partial quote from the  April 1 1972 Watchtower entitled “‘They Shall Know that a Prophet Was Among Them” sounds damming.  But what you failed to do and all the web site that I have seen that carry that fail to do is give the real meaning of that article.

For readers I have copied the entire article at the end.

In the letter I sent to Dee I made the following statement   “In Bible times a prophet was one that spoke on behalf of another. That is what JWs are. We speak on behalf of another, that one being our creator.” and further down I said “How are JW's like prophets that prophet was one that speak on behalf of our creator? In that we are sounding the warning of repentance and the drawing close of the Greta day of God the almighty. “  

The point of the article was not to show JWs as prophets that fortold future events but as a people “warning them ( the nations of this world) of dangers and calamities</b>” and of  “the blessings that God has in store  ”. Not of anything new but of what has already been spoken of. Just as in Bible times some of the people classed as  prophets that God used just gave warnings and a call to repent as they echoed previous warnings.

The article was a condemnation on the part of Christendom to uphold Gods sovereignty just as the apostate Israelites, especially at the time of Jesus,  failed to uphold Gods sovereignty.  They were / are pronouncing NOTHING new

You said
How about a brother in 1969 who said, "Hold on a minute. This 6,000 years to 1975 business is rather silly don't you think? Let us go on serving Jehovah and stop this nonsense now before we made fools of ourselves. In a few years we'll have to forget all about it and act like we never mentioned it." Do you think he would be disfellowshipped back then? You know the answer. 
End quote

I read that and, thought how little you actually seem to know. (Or to give you the benefit of the doubt ) Maybe it is just the way you worded it.  The truth is 1975 was NOT a prophecy.  It was and still is, an understanding of Bible chronology that Adam was created 6000 years before.  NO one would have been disfellowshiped back then for thinking it was nonsense and just getting on serving Jehovah.  That is just what many did, at least where I live. In 1973 we decided to build an Assembly Hall. So we set about raising money to buy land and get the funds to build. On May 1 1975 we started work on the block of land.  We were not interested in the end coming that year.

By the way I am not 100% convinced 1975 was the end of 6000 years of mans existence.  If one uses the Greek Septuagint version of the “Old Testament” the length of years of peoples ages is different and there is, form memory, at least one extra generation in that text than what is accepted in Hebrew versions of The “Old Testament”. If one accepts that version than mans 6000 years was up well before 1975. I have read compelling arguments both  for and against accepting the Septuagint years.

And you know what it does not bother me either way.  I just get on serving my creator to the best of my ability. 1975 has no real significance to Bible prophecy except to enplane that man seems to have around for 6000 years

You also say
The fact is, these very few dates that I mentioned previously were not held by Jehovah's Witness at the time as just some good understanding of scripture. No sir! As proof of point, let any Witness today say that 1914 is speculative nonsense. Will his elders say, "Oh, no big deal, 1914 is just an understanding anyway." You know what will happen.
End quote.

I assure I that those dates are held as understandings.  1914 IS just an understanding of Bible prophecy as the beginning of the time of the end, and as the time Jesus turned his attention to the earth.  Why do I say it is an understanding? Because it is not like basic Bible truths that are easily proven by scripture such as no hell, no trinity, etc.  There is compelling evidence to support that understanding, but it is JUST an understanding. 1914 is not mentioned in the Bible but the prophecies relating to 1914 all seem to fit that understanding.

Your sarcasm here tells readers you have an ax to grind

But, you say, Jehovah corrects all things in his due time. Oh yes. And if He corrects it, was it truth to start with? Was it a telling forth from Jehovah? If the teller forth needs to be corrected by Jehovah, then according to Deut. 18 it was not a word from Jehovah to start with
end quote

Again you miss the point about prophets here.  Lets look at Deuteronomy 18:15 -22 “ . 15 A prophet from your own midst, from your brothers, like me, is what Jehovah your God will raise up for you—to him YOU people should listen— 16in response to all that you asked of Jehovah your God in Ho′reb on the day of the congregation, saying, ‘Do not let me hear again the voice of Jehovah my God, and this great fire do not let me see anymore, that I may not die.’ 17 At that Jehovah said to me, ‘They have done well in speaking what they did. 18 A prophet I shall raise up for them from the midst of their brothers, like you; and I shall indeed put my words in his mouth, and he will certainly speak to them all that I shall command him. 19 And it must occur that the man who will not listen to my words that he will speak in my name, I shall myself require an account from him. 20 “‘However, the prophet who presumes to speak in my name a word that I have not commanded him to speak or who speaks in the name of other gods, that prophet must die. 21 And in case you should say in your heart: “How shall we know the word that Jehovah has not spoken?” 22 when the prophet speaks in the name of Jehovah and the word does not occur or come true, that is the word that Jehovah did not speak. With presumptuousness the prophet spoke it. You must not get frightened at him.’

There 2 things here that a prophet is said to do. In verse 22 we see the one everyone likes to pick on the false prophet whose words do not come true. Back in previous verse the prophet has a different responsibility  promoting true worship, being in harmony with God’s revealed word and commandments .

<b>JWs have never
, and I emphatic about this, no matter what you and others try to say, been a prophet in the sense of telling the future . That is what I demonstrated in my letter to Dee. No body calls those that tried to decipher the works of Nostradamus, and got it wrong as false prophets that is because it is not their work.  What JWs have done and said is not their work. When it comes to dates it is the understandings.  Our main work as “prophets “ is in the definition you also gave .. “A prophet can also be one who tells forth . Or an interpreter through whom the will of a god is expressed. There is nothing mystical or nefarious about being a prophet or even calling oneself a prophet.”

All we are doing is telling forth the message in Gods Word the Bible. That is it.  Our understandings get clouded and need adjusting.  "Truth never changes - Mans perception of it does" The more knowledge we gain the closer to truth we come.

Said in peace

PLEASE READ CAREFULLY the article that Robert alluded to

‘They Shall Know that a Prophet Was Among Them’

JEHOVAH GOD is interested in having people know him. Though he is invisible to human eyes, he provides various ways by which they can know his personality. They can know what to expect from him and what he expects of them.

One can come to understand that Jehovah is a God of surpassing wisdom by observing creation. This also reveals the loving care with which he designed things for man’s welfare and enjoyment. A second way to know God is through his Word of truth, the Bible. Herein one finds the full expression of Jehovah’s purpose toward mankind—why man is on the earth and the blessings that God has in store.

A third way of coming to know Jehovah God is through his representatives. In ancient times he sent prophets as his special messengers. While these men foretold things to come, they also served the people by telling them of God’s will for them at that time, often also warning them of dangers and calamities . People today can view the creative works. They have at hand the Bible, but it is little read or understood. So, does Jehovah have a prophet to help them, to warn them of dangers and to declare things to come ?


These questions can be answered in the affirmative. Who is this prophet? The clergy of the so-called “Christian” nations hold themselves before the people as being the ones commissioned to speak for God. But, as pointed out in the previous issue of this magazine, they have failed God and failed as proclaimers of his kingdom by approving a man-made political organization, the League of Nations (now the United Nations), as “the political expression of the Kingdom of God on earth.”

However, Jehovah did not let the people of Christendom, as led by the clergy, go without being warned that the League was a counterfeit substitute for the real kingdom of God. He had a “prophet” to warn them. This “prophet” was not one man, but was a body of men and women. It was the small group of footstep followers of Jesus Christ, known at that time as International Bible Students. Today they are known as Jehovah’s Christian witnesses. They are still proclaiming a warning , and have been joined and assisted in their commissioned work by hundreds of thousands of persons who have listened to their message with belief.

Of course, it is easy to say that this group acts as a “prophet” of God. It is another thing to prove it. The only way that this can be done is to review the record. What does it show?

During the World War I period this group, the International Bible Students, was very active in preaching the good news of God’s kingdom, as their Leader Jesus Christ had set this work before them in his prophecy at Matthew 24:14. They took literally Jesus’ words to the Roman governor Pontius Pilate: “My kingdom is no part of this world.” (John 18:36) They also took to heart Jesus’ words to his followers: “You are no part of the world, but I have chosen you out of the world.” They expected to suffer for living according to that rule, just as Jesus went on to say, “on this account the world hates you.” (John 15:19) Hatred toward them grew into violence during World War I.

These Bible Students had long been concerned with Ezekiel and his prophecy. In 1917 they published a book entitled “The Finished Mystery,” explaining the book of Ezekiel as well as that of Revelation. This book criticized the clergy as false to the Word of Jehovah. Within nine months a ban was put on its circulation in the United States and Canada. Then eight members of the Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society, including its president and secretary-treasurer, were sentenced to prison in the Federal penitentiary, Atlanta, Georgia, U.S.A.

Though the work of these Christians was crippled for a while, after only nine months the eight men were freed from prison, in March 1919. They accepted this as an answer from God to their prayers. Their work was revived, much to the consternation of the clergy, who had been behind the banning.

Accordingly, their magazine The Watch Tower and Herald of Christ’s Presence, in its issues of August 1 and 15, 1919, encouraged vigorous resumption of the work of preaching the good news free from the fear of men. Under the subject “Blessed Are the Fearless,” the following statements were made:

“There is a fear which is very proper, and which everyone must have who is pleasing to God, and this is known as ‘Godly fear’. It means a holy reverence for Jehovah and a fear lest we should displease him and come short of the blessings he has promised us. . . . The Scriptures abound with testimony that those whom God approves do not fear man nor any other creature, but have a holy, reverential fear of Jehovah. In times of old Jehovah justified some men to friendship with him, and the record of his dealing with them was written for the benefit of the church.”

Ezekiel was one of these men so used by God, and not only his prophecies, but also Ezekiel himself and his acts were pictorial of things to come.


A General Convention was held by the International Bible Students at Cedar Point, Ohio, September 1-8, 1919. Thousands of Jehovah’s servants were present from the United States and Canada. There the Watch Tower Society’s president urged the fearless resumption of the work, and this with the use of the outspoken magazine entitled “The Golden Age.” In the public talk delivered on the subject “The Hope for Distressed Humanity,” the speaker declared that the Lord’s displeasure was certain to be visited upon the League of Nations,

“because the clergy—Catholic and Protestant—claiming to be God’s representatives, have abandoned his plan and endorsed the League of Nations, hailing it as a political expression of Christ’s kingdom on earth.”

The League of Nations came into being in 1919 and began really to function when it was ratified by the signatory powers at Paris on January 10, 1920. But Jehovah’s servants continued to proclaim the Messianic kingdom of God. When the ban on The Finished Mystery was lifted, they resumed its circulation and, with it as a textbook, they continued to study the book of Ezekiel. As time went on and further developments fulfilled the prophecy of Ezekiel, a three-volume set of books titled “Vindication” provided an up-to-date understanding, showing more fully the application of the prophecy.

Thus this group of anointed followers of Jesus Christ, doing a work in Christendom paralleling Ezekiel’s work among the Jews, were manifestly the modern-day Ezekiel, the “prophet” commissioned by Jehovah to declare the good news of God’s Messianic kingdom and to give warning to Christendom. It is significant that, in 1931, after twelve years of faithful service despite the opposition of Christendom’s clergy, these followers of Christ embraced the name “Jehovah’s witnesses” at the same convention at which the book Vindication was released.—Isa. 43:10-12, American Standard Version.


When Jehovah spoke to the Jewish priest Ezekiel, commissioning him as his prophet, he said: “Son of man, I am sending you to the sons of Israel, to rebellious nations that have rebelled against me.” (Ezek. 2:3) Who are those who constitute the “sons of Israel” and the “rebellious nations” against Jehovah, in this “time of the end”?

Back there in Ezekiel’s day the Israelite people to whom Ezekiel was sent could be called “rebellious nations” because in 997 B.C.E. ten of the tribes of Israel had revolted against rule by the royal line of David, who sat on “Jehovah’s throne.” (1 Chron. 29:23) Thus there came to be two kingdoms or “nations.” The Kingdom of Israel set up golden calves for worship and the Kingdom of Judah later also rebelled against Jehovah by breaking his laws and engaging in idolatry.

In the modern fulfillment, who are the “rebellious nations” that have rebelled against Jehovah? Their counterpart is Christendom. The Bible gives the proof. For Christendom has applied to herself the apostle Paul’s words at Galatians 6:15, 16 (Authorized Version): “For in Christ Jesus neither circumcision availeth any thing, nor uncircumcision, but a new creature. And as many as walk according to this rule, peace be on them, and mercy, and upon the Israel of God.” For instance, in his “A Commentary and Critical Notes” (1836 edition), the Wesleyan Methodist minister Dr. Adam Clarke makes this comment on the expression “The Israel of God”: “The true Christians, called here the Israel of God, to distinguish them from Israel according to the flesh.”

Romans 2:29 (AV) corroborates the above understanding. The apostle says: “But he is a Jew, which is one inwardly; and circumcision is that of the heart, in the spirit, and not in the letter; whose praise is not of men, but of God.”

The history of Christendom shows that she has not been true to her claim of being “the Israel of God.” From the fourth century on she has shown herself to be apostate, rebellious against Jehovah and his Word of truth. Corresponding to Israel’s history, there was a break between the Greek churches and the Latin churches in 1054 C.E., when the Roman pope’s legates excommunicated Patriarch Michael Cerularius of Constantinople.

Later, in 1529 C.E., the Protestant movement was established by the followers of ex-priest Martin Luther, and in 1534 the king of England, Henry VIII, was declared to be the Supreme Head of the Church of England. After this, numerous non-Roman Catholic sects sprang up, so that a number of so-called “Christian” lands have their own national State churches. Therefore Christendom can be called “nations,” and their attitude toward God’s Word the Bible and toward his Messianic kingdom is one of rebellion toward Jehovah. They continue to prefer political man-rule.


Ezekiel’s name meant “God Strengthens,” and in order to carry out his mission to the end he needed God’s help, for the professed people of God to whom he was sent were “insolent of face and hard of heart.” At the time, they might not view or appreciate him as a prophet of Jehovah. Nevertheless, whether they paid attention to him or refrained, the occasion was to come when these rebellious people would “know also that a prophet himself happened to be in the midst of them.” Jehovah would confirm him as a prophet then by causing what Ezekiel prophesied to come true. (Ezek. 2:3-5) Ezekiel was further told:

“And you, O son of man, do not be afraid of them; and of their words do not be afraid, because there are obstinate ones and things pricking you and it is among scorpions that you are dwelling. Of their words do not you be afraid, and at their faces do not you be struck with terror, for they are a rebellious house. And you must speak my words to them, regardless of whether they hear or they refrain, for they are a case of rebellion.”—Ezek. 2:6, 7.

Since the year 1919 C.E. Jehovah’s witnesses have found circumstances to be just like that as they have made the widest possible declaration of the good news of the Kingdom in 207 lands of the earth.

To Ezekiel, in his vision, and, symbolically to the modern-day “prophet,” the spirit-begotten, anointed ones who are the nucleus of Jehovah’s witnesses today, God gave something to eat. Ezekiel says:

“And I began to see, and, look! there was a hand thrust out to me, and, look! in it there was the roll of a book. And he gradually spread it out before me, and it was written upon in front and on the back; and there were written in it dirges and moaning and wailing.”—Ezek. 2:8-10.

No space on the scroll being wasted, it being written upon on both sides, it was a full message, containing a great deal of gloomy messages of calamity, back there to Jewry, and today to Christendom. Why so? Because in both instances Jehovah’s professed people were so rebellious and set in their ungodly way that Jehovah had to pronounce judgment upon them.

The scroll was doubtless delivered to Ezekiel by the hand of one of the cherubs in the vision. This would indicate that Jehovah’s witnesses today make their declaration of the good news of the Kingdom under angelic direction and support. (Rev. 14:6, 7; Matt. 25:31, 32) And since no word or work of Jehovah can fail, for he is God Almighty, the nations will see the fulfillment of what these witnesses say as directed from heaven.

Yes, the time must come shortly that the nations will have to know that really a “prophet” of Jehovah was among them. Actually now more than a million and a half persons are helping that collective or composite “prophet” in his preaching work and well over that number of others are studying the Bible with the “prophet” group and its companions.

So Jehovah has made every provision for individuals to know him and to receive his loving-kindness and life. Thus there is no excuse for Christendom’s people not to know Jehovah. More than that, Jehovah is interested not only in the vindication of his own name but also in vindicating his “prophet.” Through another of his ancient prophets, Isaiah, he said to Jewry just as he says to Christendom today: “Look! My own servants will cry out joyfully because of the good condition of the heart, but you yourselves will make outcries because of the pain of heart and you will howl because of sheer breakdown of spirit.”—Isa. 65:14.

Even today we hear complaints from Christendom’s churches about dwindling church attendance and see many young men abandoning the priesthood and the ministerial profession. Yet at the same time we see spiritual prosperity and contentment among those proclaiming Jehovah’s Messianic kingdom. We may look for an even more marked fulfillment of Isaiah’s words in the near future.

Hello Brenton,

No offense taken at all. I wanted to reply to make sure that your posting of WT April 1 1972 is available for any to read who have an interest.

There are things about the The Watchtower organization that I cannot abide by, otherwise I would still be a whole-hearted supporter of the organization as I once was. Thank you for hinting at the distinction between the people of Jehovah's Witnesses and the machine called Watchtower Society. Sadly, most Jehovah's Witnesses equate serving God with loyalty to an organization.

What I take issue with the most is how we never tire of condemning everything outside the organization while praising ourselves for all sorts of imagined grandiose things about ourselves. Have you not noticed the relentless praise of ourselves and put-downs of others? This mindset permeates everything that is Watchtower. You demonstrate this yourself with your comment, "The article was a condemnation on the part of Christendom to uphold Gods sovereignty just as the apostate Israelites, especially at the time of Jesus, failed to uphold Gods sovereignty."

You, actually we, heap everything called Christian that is outside of Watchtower into a group for condemnation. You, we, presume to know that none of them uphold God's sovereignty and they are likened to apostate Israelites. This mindset is at the core of everything Watchtower and it sickens me to no end.

I don't have to remind you of "you with the rafter". But somehow that applies to anyone not us.

Aside from that, do you realize just how many things we teach that are not in the Bible but are simply understandings? For example:

--The Great Crowd should not partake of the emblems at Memorial. Where does the Bible say that partaking is for the purpose of signifying ones destiny? Nowhere. John 6:53, 54 and John 14:6.

--Similarly, where does the Bible say that the Great Crowd is an earthly group? Nowhere.

--Where does the Bible say that Jesus and Jehovah would inspect all Christian groups during 1914-1919 and would subsequently choose one "group" and cast off all other "groups"? Nowhere.

--Where in the Bible does Jesus pray to one called "Jehovah" or make an issue of pronouncing "Jehovah" to the crowds? Nowhere.

We say that everything we teach comes directly from the Bible and we are so quick to judge as rejected by Jehovah anyone that does not believe these understandings. Do you think, Brother Brenton, that a believer should be free to make up his own mind about these things and still have a good relationship with God? If you had a belief issue with 1 or 2 of these, or even something else not specifically in the Bible, would you still be accepted as a brother in the Kingdom Hall?

Robert Jones

Jehovah`s Witness

All Answers

Answers by Expert:

Ask Experts


Robert Jones


1. How the organization of Jehovah's Witnesses is stuctured, how it operates, and how it exercises control over its members. 2. What Jehovah's Witnesses believe, why, and who determines doctrine.

It is a waste of time to argue with Jehovah's Witnesses or to present lists of scriptural proofs to show where they are in error. Jehovah's Witnesses listen only the "Faithful and Discreet Slave" and immediately accept changes that come through the pages of The Watchtower magazine.


I survived 1975. For 32 years, from 1968 to 2000, I embraced and promoted everything coming through Jehovah's sole channel of communication, the "Faithful and Discreet Slave." I accepted doctrinal changes as "new light", meat in due season, from the Slave Class.

Was an elder the last 13 years, WT Study Conductor, Congregation Secretary, Book Study Conductor, and occasional Pioneer. Never "irregular" or "inactive" as the labels go. I have not been reproved or disfellowshipped. I no longer attend meetings or practice the religion. I have not started smoking, drinking, gambling, using drugs, or had any sort of emotional breakdown. How silly.

I am not a servant of the "Faithful and Discreet Slave", the WTBTS, or any other man-made organization. I hope to explain, not defend, the beliefs of Jehovah's Witnesses. I believe in universal truths such as kindness, humility, charity, and love. I do not believe that God selected a special group, the Jews or CT Russell followers for example, to receive a special message or blessing. I do not believe that one religion has it all right and therfore other religions are wrong. I believe it is a delusion for one group of humans to claim that "God chose us and therefore God did not choose you." I consider spirituality to be a personal endeavor that each person must discover for themselves.

Degree in Computer Programming. Not applicable here.

©2017 All rights reserved.