You are here:

Military History/Who would you consider the "good guys" in WW1?

Advertisement


Question
well, my question for the expert is a random one.

I will be asking more questions here maybe soon.

So my question, where there "good guys" in WW1? Is it possible that you could consider Germany and the Central powers the "good guys" in World War 1?

Or where the allies the "good guys"?

I would like a very detailed answer to the question.

Thank you! ^-^

Answer
There is no such thing as "good guys", only "bad guys", "badder guys", and "baddest guys". In short, human beings.

No one can judge the character of individual soldiers who have long since died; which nations are "good" or "bad" is largely a subjective matter.

Personally, I tend to sympathize with the Central Powers because thats where my ancestors were from (and it's the area of the world that I study).

Because this is such a subjective matter, it is impossible to give an academic detailed answer.

Military History

All Answers


Answers by Expert:


Ask Experts

Volunteer


Isaac Edmondson

Expertise

Topics on which I can provide answers: European warfare and military affairs from 1600 to 1950. Israeli / Islamic conflicts from 1900 to present day. Areas of particular interest/knowledge: The German Peasantís War. Hannover and Brunswick during the Napoleonic wars. Armor (Tanks) during the first and second world wars. Topics best left to other experts: Military history of Eastern Asia, Sub-Saharan Africa, South America and India.

Experience

Numerous (not for publishing) papers written on relevant topics and countless pleasant hours spent researching.

Education/Credentials
Currently enrolled at the University of Maine

©2016 About.com. All rights reserved.