Nirvana/Meaning?

Advertisement


Question
What is the meaning of "you know your right"?

its seems very powerful, almost like Kurt wants to break from heroin i mean come on "I would never bother you
I would never promise to
I will never follow you
I will never bother you
Never say a word again
I will crawl away for good"  

Answer
Hello Ted,

Since NIRVANA hasnt actually spoken publically about the song, and It was only recorded as being played once prior to the death of Kurt, not counting courtneys version. We may never know for sure, there will always be speculations becuase Kurt never said "Hey its about this" but i offer you this bit of information, and hope it helps.

Nirvana recorded this a few months before Kurt Cobain killed himself in 1994. It was the last song the band recorded.
The group recorded this when they had some spare time one weekend. It was not intended for any specific album, so when Cobain died, it went unreleased.
Kurt wrote this song as a sarcastic reference to his wife Courtney Love, at a very turbulent time in their relationship (shortly before his suicide), the title and predominant lyric: "you know your right" and also "nothing really bothers her, she just wants to love herself", both refer to Kurt's frustration with Courtney. (thanks, Matt - Lincoln, NE)
When Cobain died, the 2 remaining members (Dave Grohl and Krist Novoselic) formed a partnership with his widow, Courtney Love, that controlled the rights to Nirvana's songs. Grohl and Novoselic wanted to release this sooner, but Love refused, and it was not until 2002 that they reached an agreement where she allowed a Nirvana Greatest Hits CD with this on it. As part of the agreement, the Universal Music Group, which released the CD, let Love out of her contract with the label.
Grohl went years without listening to this. Until it was mixed for the Greatest Hits album, he didn't even have a copy of it.
Nirvana performed this only once, and it was not filmed.
Before Nirvana released this, Courtney Love played a live acoustic version of it called "You've Got No Right" for an MTV Unplugged special with her band Hole. She sang "Hey" instead of "Pain." Here's how she introduced the song: "This is a song that Kurt wrote. We worked on it a little bit, we can't do it that well but it's Valentine's Day, and maybe he can hear it, and he'll go, 'You know, you really f---ed up my song, Courtney. Don't even try it.' But if it works, it's dedicated to my mother-in-law.

Sincerely,
Jennifer Hollman

Nirvana

All Answers


Answers by Expert:


Ask Experts

Volunteer


Jennifer Hollman

Expertise

I can answer questions about the release history of NIRVANA from 1989-Present, questions about the history of the band, life & death of Kurt Cobain, the remaining members of NIRVANA, and most questions about his family. I can fact check tour dates, live shows, and just about anything related.

Experience

I helped out Carrie Borzillo, rock new editor for cdnow.com (now amazon.com) with fact checking, an interview, eyewitness account and was given special thanks in her book Eyewitness Nirvana. I've been studying NIRVANA since 1993 and have read literally thousands of books, magazine articles, and other publications throughout the last decade and a half. My reference collection is huge with just about every book, entire release catalog, and more from all around the world. I started volunteering for AllExpterts.com in 1999 before it was purchased by About.com sometime in the early 00's. You can find all of the answers to previously asked public question dating back to 1999. I wrote, edited, and published a NIRVANA newsletter (NIRVANA FOREVER), and online zine (About a Son; Lithium) that both ran 7 years on America Online. I've founded and sistered a lot of NIRVANA communities on LiveJournal.com (NIRVANA FOREVER, Kurt & Jim, and NIRVANA Elitests), and Yahoo.com (NIRVANA FOREVER).

Education/Credentials
There are no Educational credentials required for this category.

©2012 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company. All rights reserved.