You are here:

Nutrition & Dieting/Which replacement for Diet Coke is better?


Dear Stacy,

Thank you for offering your time to us here. I've finally weaned myself off of Diet Coke (after 40-something years)! and I'm testing two different drinks, but don't know which one is overall a better drink:

One is ITO EN's Tea's Tea:

The other is Sparkling Ice Naturally Flavored Spring Water (I drink most flavors but prefer Lemon/Lime):

The latter has more vitamins, but it also has sucralose and mannitol. Which do you think is better, overall?

Thank you,

Hi Elizabeth,

I think that the ITO tea would be a better alternative.  The reason is that it does not list any additives, chemicals, or coloring.  The Sparkling Ice, while it has zero calories, is filled with artificial ingredients. The tea is high in caffeine so please keep that in mind.  Hope this helps to answer your question.

Healthy regards,

Nutrition & Dieting

All Answers

Answers by Expert:

Ask Experts


Stacy Ostrager, M.A.,M.S.


I am qualified to answer your questions on nutrition, medical nutrition therapy, disease management,obesity and obesity related issues. I am experienced with nutrition aspect of managing the following: Celiac disease, lactose intolerance, pregnancy, allergies, IBS, diabetes, heart disease, fitness, wellness, healthy cooking, and many more.


Over 20 years in premier hospitals, consulting and private counseling practice for nutrition.

New York State Dietetic Association, Long Island Dietetic Association, Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics, Center for Science of Public Interest

Masters of Healthcare Administration from Hofstra University (Hempstead, N.Y.) 1999 Masters of Science in Nutrition from Eastern Michigan University (Ypslanti, M.I.) 2012 Bachelor of Science in Healthcare Administration from Ithaca College (Ithaca, N.Y) 1994

Past/Present Clients
NYU Medical Center, Long Island Jewish Medical Center

©2017 All rights reserved.