AllExperts > PC hardware--CPU & Motherboard & RAM 
Search      
PC hardware--CPU & Motherboard & RAM
Volunteer
Answers to thousands of questions
 Home · More PC hardware--CPU & Motherboard & RAM Questions · Answer Library  · Encyclopedia ·
More PC hardware--CPU & Motherboard & RAM Answers
Question Library

Ask a question about PC hardware--CPU & Motherboard & RAM
Volunteer
Experts of the Month
Expert Login

Awards

About Us
Tell friends
Link to Us
Disclaimer

 
 
 
 
About Mike
Expertise
Areas of expertise: PC Hardware, Peripherals, Barcode Scanners, Printers, and Applications, Networking, Microsoft Applications. I am good at researching issues and have a lot of contacts in the IT industry. So, if I can't directly answer a question I can likely find the answer. Areas I won't be much help in: Apple Computers, Linux, older Networking technologies like Token Ring, or Thick/Thinnet.

Experience
I'm currently a Network Administrator for a contract circuit board manufacturer in Oregon, USA. I've been working on PCs from a hobby standpoint for better than 25 years. I've been doing it professionally for 4 years.

Education/Credentials
A+ Certification, Network + Certification, MCP, MCDST, MCSA (in process)

 
   

You are here:  Experts > Computing/Technology > Focus on PC Support > PC hardware--CPU & Motherboard & RAM > graphic card or asus board

PC hardware--CPU & Motherboard & RAM - graphic card or asus board


Expert: Mike - 6/5/2009

Question
QUESTION: hi.....

i kinda confuse in selecting for graphic card or asus nvidia chipset motherboard(p5 n7a vm)..
my sys config is:
P4 3.2GHz
intel D945GTP motherboard..
512mb ddr2 (533Mhz)
i think my fsb is only 1066Mhz :(...

my question are :-

should i go for 9600GT ddr2 (1GB) or 9500GT ddr3(1GB).. i don't know are they compatible with my system or not?
and should i buy asus p5 n7a vm motherboard which has GF 9300GT 512mb graphic card inbuilt..?

(some of my friends suggested for whole system upgrade but then i can't buy any seprate video card)

ANSWER:  Honestly, it depends on what you do with your computer and how much money you want to spend.
You have a pretty decent motherboard now and that 9600GT DDR2 actually performs better than the DDR3 card and it is probably less expensive.
Personally, I would keep your motherboard and get the 9600GT card. My only suggestion would be to put the money you save towards more memory, like upgrade from 512MB to at least 1GB of RAM.

---------- FOLLOW-UP ----------

QUESTION: yes i also think so .. i will upgrade my ram to 2GB but which one 533Mhz or 667Mhz or 800Mhz  and if i choose different frequecy ram will it degrade my system performance ..

also are their any compatibility issue in graphic card ??,, i am not so good with hardware so plz guide ...  me to decent graphic card for my sys

my sys config is:
P4 3.2GHz
intel D945GTP motherboard..
512mb ddr2 (533Mhz)
my power supply is of 400W

i want my to play games likes crysis,fear,farcry

ANSWER:  That motherboard can't handle anything higher than 667MHz RAM so that is what you should buy. The higher the MHz number, the faster the memory so it's the best choice.

As far as video cards go, you should have no compatibility issues with that 9600GT card and it should be more than capable of handling the games you want to play.

---------- FOLLOW-UP ----------

QUESTION: thanks...

but can i use my old 512mb (533Mhz) with new 2GB (667Mhz) .. what will be the affect of using different frequency rams...???

and there is one problem with video card selection is that i don't want to buy additional psu...(my budget is limited)

also my friends suggested me few cards but i don't know their compatibility and psu requirement ..they suggest me
-ATI Radon HD4760
-8800GT or GTX
-9600GT
-9500GT
, but which would U personally choose considering no compatibility issue(board ram processor), no psu upgrade , limited money and my system config

Answer
It isn't recommended to run more than one speed of memory in the same system but you can. What happens is that the faster memory slows itself down to match the slower memory.

Unless you are planning on replacing all of your ram with 667MHz I would simply buy another 1.5GB of the 533Mhz memory and add it to what you are using now. This saves you some money since you'll still be able to use what you are currently using in your computer and they will run more smoothly together.

Also, I still feel that the 9600GT video card is a good choice. nVidia is a much better video card manufacturer than ATi.
At most that card pulls 96 watts so your current 400w power supply is big enough to handle that card without any real problems.

Add to this Answer   Ask a Question


 
User Agreement | Privacy Policy | Kids' Privacy Policy | Help
Copyright  © 2008 About, Inc. AllExperts, AllExperts.com, and About.com are registered trademarks of About, Inc. All rights reserved.