Paranormal Phenomena/Ghosts and energy.

Advertisement


Question
Hi,
I recently was looking on a web site for a group here in California that explores the paranormal as I was curious about ghosts and some stuff that has been happening in my home. One web site said that ghosts exist because of Newtons law that energy can not be destroyed but only changes. If this is true and people are energy doesn't this prove that ghosts exist? Any information would help. Thanks in advance! :)

Answer
Hello Macy,

 Your question is interesting in so many ways. First that a paranormal group would attribute the First Law of Thermodynamics, the Conservation of Energy principle to someone who died 150 years before its concept. Newton's work may have laid certain ground work, but he had nothing to do with the actual theory and proof of the conservation of energy discovery.

 That being said the 1st law [of thermodynamics - which I will here on shorten to the 1st law]has been stated over and over again as being 'scientific proof' of the survival of personality or mind after physical death by many new agers, psychics and mediums and of course more than a few paranormal group. Simply put the law states that energy can be neither created nor destroyed in a closed system - that it can only change states. Now that does lend some validity to energy not dying when we die, but not completely. First of all, all of our physical, that is to say material, energy is spoken for. We decompose, and that feeds micro organisms, we heat up so some energy is used as heat. When we have finished feeding our body energy to the bacteria we are left as a bunch of bones which is in essence potential energy. Yup, all of that energy is accounted for.

 That leaves us with what one could call psychic energy or the energy of the mind. There are only two ways for this energy to react to death. It either remains the same, or some of it is lost from living to death as heat. The second law of thermodynamics, which psychics, new agers and the like tend to ignore is the fly in the ointment. That law states that there is never an equal exchange of energy from one state to another, that some is always lost as heat [the 'thermo' part of thermodynamics]. This is what is known as Entropy. Even if this subtle energy were to survive the transfer from life to death unchanged, it would likely lose energy to entropy during ghostly contact or activity. If one is to use one of the laws of thermodynamics to present a case for ghosts, then one must abide by ALL of the laws of thermodynamics. It's like the song says, "...you can't have one without the other."

 So you can see that nothing so far can absolutely prove the existence of ghosts. On the other hand so far there is nothing that can absolutely disprove the existence of ghosts.The 1st law would be able to account for life after death provided no contact from the spirit realm to the physical realm was made. Once a large exchange of energy is required, for contact for example, entropy rears its head.

 One more thing about thermodynamics is that eventually all energy will burn out, known as heat death. That means that eternity will have to exist in near absolute zero [minus 459 degrees F].

 Of course, we have no idea how the laws of physics may exist in another dimension, so the laws may not apply there as they would here. It is impossible to use science developed and used in our three dimensional concept of reality to explore a 4th or better dimension. The truth is that we may never be able to prove anything beyond a reasonable doubt as all to the evidence so far is circumstantial. I personally have seen more than one full body apparition, and try as I might, science can not either explain what I saw nor convince me that I didn't experience what I've seen. Kirk was wrong, space is not the final frontier, death is.

 I hope that I helped in some way. Basically my answer is that there are no absolute answers in this field. There are so many variables. Again it is hard to apply our set of scientific facts with elements that may forever be out of our reach or understanding - while we live at least.

Take care,

Paranormal Phenomena

All Answers


Answers by Expert:


Ask Experts

Volunteer


Greg Pocha

Expertise

Ghosts - Hauntings - Paranormal & Preternatural Phenomena - Parapsychology - Death/Afterlife Studies

Director of Parapsychology and Paranormal Studies (Eidolon Project Canada)

Mr.Pocha will not accept Donations, "Prestige Points" or Ratings.

Greg shares his experience and knowledge as a special consultant on All Experts to help people find educated and unbiased answers from a professional in the field. He will be happy to answer your questions on the following subjects:Greg is the head of the Eidolon Project Canada, one of Canada's largest and best established Paranormal Investigation organizations. He and his team of professional investigators spend hours investigating hauntings and analyzing their findings. He has helped people internationally understand and deal with their paranormal activity. When giving an answer through All Experts the questioner can expect to be treated as an individual and given a thought out educated reply that will take in different aspects regarding their unique situation.

Experience

Greg Pocha is the Director of Parapsychology and Paranormal Studies for the Eidolon Project Canada. Mr. Pocha is also a leading authority on 'Spectral Profiling'. He has been actively researching and investigating the paranormal in relation to ghosts, hauntings, paranormal activity, parapsychology, psychical research and other closely related areas as a professional since 1999 although his interest and study of the paranormal goes back nearly a half century. He is one of the founders of 'Eidolon Project Canada', an organization that researchs and investigates hauntings at no cost to their clients. Besides studying the subjects that most people consider 'paranormal', Greg also studies subjects such as Near Death Experiences, and other scientific areas. Greg has instructed the Paranormal Studies course for Edmonton Public School's Adult Continuing Education department. He has also given seminars for Edmonton Public Libraries programs. Greg continues adding to his knowledge through study and his continued active involvement in research and investigations of hauntings throughout his home province of Alberta, Canada. Mr. Pocha has been called in to offer his expertise and assist in independent investigations. His input and opinions are sought after and respected.



Publications
Greg is currently writing his first book, "BEYOND: Recognition {Ghosts, Hauntings and Spectral Profiling}". Note: This is an actual book, not a vanity published e-book.

Education/Credentials

Outside of practical hands-on experience and field work for over a decade, Greg owns a private reference library approaching 1,000 books dealing with the paranormal, ghosts, hauntings, parapsychology, physics, medical and other related subject. Here is a subject sampling of this extensive library:GHOSTS - HAUNTINGS - POLTERGEIST - CLASSICAL & QUANTUM THEORY - ENCYCLOPEDIAS / DICTIONARIES / ANTHOLOGIES on PARANORMAL STUDIES - TEXTS on PARAPSYCHOLOGY - DEMONOLOGY - CASE STUDIES - INVESTIGATIVE TECHNIQUES - HISTORY / MYTHOLOGY of GHOSTS - THANATOLOGY - NEAR DEATH STUDIES - HOSPICE CARE - PSYCHICAL STUDIES - BEHAVIORAL PSYCHOLOGY - etc.. Authors include: Sigmund Freud, Carl Jung, Albert Einstein, Stephan Hawking, Paul Davis, Carl Sagan, Allison DuBois, James van Praagh, Derek Achora, John Robert Columbo, Dr.Raymond Moody Jr., Dr.Elisabeth Kubler-Ross, Dr. Maurice Rawlings, Dr.Melvin Morse, Dr.Janis Amatuzio, Dr. Kenneth Ring, Dr. Jeffrey Long, Harry Price, Hans Holzer, Andrew Lang, Ed & Lorraine Warren, A.Arthur Findlay, Nandor Fudor, Colin Wilson, Plato, DeCarte, Nietzshce, et.al. This ever growing library is available should references need to be made to help in answering your questions. Greg's on-going education in the paranormal and parapsychology fields is unending.



Past/Present Clients
Due to confidentiality agreements made with our clients guaranteeing their anonymity, I can not list past/current clients. All of our investigations are refered to by case number only. Personal information regarding our clients is privileged.

©2016 About.com. All rights reserved.