You are here:

Philosophy/Abnormal What if question?

Advertisement


Question
What would you do if you were stuck in a room for eternity. The room is underwater and you can not breathe, you are also being tortured. If the pain only gets even worse and you can not die/ leave room and you can only ever think about the situation you're in. I have pondered this situation for a long time and am looking for something (ie an idea) that can satisfy me by finding some idea or something satisfying in this situation (theoretical situation of course). Please stop and truly think about this, as the person really can't do anything as this is the worst possible theoretical thing that can happen to anything ever, so what do you think can satisfy? Thank you so very much.

Answer
Hi Pelly,

Thanks for the morbid question.

It sounds as though I'm left with few options. I can neither leave nor die. I'm assuming these are absolutes rather than extremely difficult to accomplish but possible. To inject some real world practicality, I think one's mind/body would respond on its own in short order with unconsciousness, shock, and/or psychosis. I would guess and hope that unconsciousness would be the net result when all is said and done, perhaps passing through shock and/or psychosis first.

Just some educated guesses!

Peace,
Michael :)

Philosophy

All Answers


Answers by Expert:


Ask Experts

Volunteer


Michael J. Motta

Expertise

Existentialism, existential psychology, political philosophy; some value theory and ethics. Interdisciplinary approach to the social sciences and humanities: some background in abnormal psychology, expressionist art, and modern literature. I'd defer to other experts especially in areas such as analytic philosophy and philosophy of science.

Experience

Tutor, Michigan State University, Student-Athlete Support Services, 2002-2005. Teaching Assistant, Binghamton University, Department of Philosophy, 1995.
Organizations
American Civil Liberties Union

Organizations
American Civil Liberties Union Michigan Audubon Society

Publications
The Society for Laingian Studies (giardino delle parole), Lansing State Journal, Grand Ledge Independent, beTurtle.com, Property Investor Magazine, Grand Rapids Press, eHow.com

Education/Credentials
Graduate study, Binghamton University, Department of Philosophy, 1993-95. MA in Philosophy, Michigan State University, College of Arts and Letters, 1991. Master's thesis: "Nietzsche's 'Hothouse For Strange And Choice Plants'". BA in Social Science, Michigan State University, James Madison College, 1989. Study abroad: Cambridge University, Trinity College, Cambridge, England, 1988.

Awards and Honors
Clifford D. Clark Fellow, Binghamton University, 1993-95. Department of Philosophy Fellowship, Michigan State University, 1991. National Merit Scholar, Michigan State University, 1985-1989.

©2016 About.com. All rights reserved.