You are here:

Puzzle Solving/30 year old puzzle

Advertisement


Question
I've been struggling with this one since taking a statistics course in University in 1976.  I'll try to draw the puzzle as it was presented to me:

         *   *

     *   *   *   *

     *   *   *   *

         *   *

The challenge is this:
Join all of the dots along the horizontal, vertical and diagonals (resulting in an image looking something like 5 envelopes adjacent to each other) without retracing any line, by using just five continuous lines.  I hope I've explained that adequately.  The resulting image is like this:

   *--*
   !\ /!
   !/ \!
*--*--*--*
!\ /!\ /!\ /!
!/ \!/ \!/ \!
*--*--*--*
   !\ /!
   !/ \!
   *--*
Not very good, but the best I can do with the typeface.  I think you'll get the idea.  I've been "doodling with this for over 30 years and can always do it with 6 lines, but have only (I think) done it a couple of times with 5 (maybe I was dreaming?)

Was I dreaming, or is it actually possible??
Regards,
Jim

!/ \!

!/ \!


Answer
I don't know if I've understood your question properly or not. But in case I have, then I have a solution.

First lets assign a variable to each of the dots to help us communicate better.

   a b
 c d e f
 g h i j
   k l

line 1 - from c to just right of f (covers c,d,e,f)
line 2 - from just right of f to below k (covers j,l)
line 3 - from below k to above a (covers k,h,d,a)
line 4 - from above a to just right of j (covers b,f)
line 5 - from just right of j to g (covers j,i,h,g)

In case this is not what you are looking then please don't hesitate to post again.
============================================================
IN CASE YOU WANT FASTER SOLUTIONS TO YOUR PROBLEMS, THEN PLEASE DONATE ME SOME MONEY SO THAT I CAN GET A BROADBAND CONNECTION. PLEASE DONATE TO rohitagarwaliitd@gmail.com

Puzzle Solving

All Answers


Answers by Expert:


Ask Experts

Volunteer


Rohit Agarwal

Expertise

I can answer questions related to numbers and logic easily. However I sometimes face problems when solving questions that require a lot of creative thinking. I am not good at puzzles which involve a play with words, so please don't ask me to solve such puzzles for you.

Experience

I have read a couple of good books containing puzzles and can now claim to have an "expert" in this field. I have been invited to become a member of Mensa.

Organizations
INDIAN INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT, LUCKNOW

Education/Credentials
I did Dual Degree (B.Tech M.Tech) in Electrical Engineering Department from INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY, DELHI I am doing MBA in Finance from INDIAN INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT, LUCKNOW

Awards and Honors
Numerous certificates recognizing my ability in Mathematics and Logical Thinking

©2012 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company. All rights reserved.