Roofing/Roof Leaking


The roof is leaking and here is the history.  I hope you can help me. My carpenter (note- not a roofer) is building a porch for me.  There is a skylight and this roof is 3 sided one covering the porch and attached to the house on one side.  He did not use any ice/water shield and the roof is leaking now.  It's a very slight pitch and normally we would have used rolled paper but I'm allergic to the smell so he shingled.  Now it won't stop leaking in the area surrounding the skylight.  He also didn't use any flashing....guy tood 2 weeks, long days to do this job and the room is only 8x14.  Now that the damage has been done..what is the solution?
Thanks for your help.

Shingles are not to be installed on a slope less than 2:12, and even then must have a double layer of underlayment (between 4:12 and 2:12). You indicate that there is a slight pitch which I assume means is a "low slope" - meaning less than 2:12. This is inappropriate for shingle installation and you must have a watertight installation #shingles are "water-shedding" implying that they rely on the slope to aid in the prevention of moisture intrusion#. If the slope is greater than 2:12, please respond and we will see if there are other options.
I'm sorry but the only solution is to remove the shingles and install an appropriate "low-slope" roofing material. The material should extend up the curb of the skylight such that the sheet metal frame covers the membrane #it is recommended to cover by a minimum of 4"#. You note that you are allergic to the smell of the rolled roofing #I'm assuming that it is the asphalt smell that causes you problems#. There are other low-slope appropriate membranes such as PVC, KEE, EPDM, TPO or other such single-ply membranes which do not have the asphalt smell. I would recommend that you contact a roofing contractor to have them install the correct materials.
Sorry that you are having leaking and I hope that this helps,


All Answers

Answers by Expert:

Ask Experts


Aaron Nelson


All types of questions with regard to roofing, waterproofing and sheet metal. This includes commercial and residential buildings, along with the various aspects of the construction means and methods, ventilation, steep-slope or low-slope, code requirements, installation errors and other such problems


I started in roofing fabricating and installing sheet metal flashings out of high school for a large commercial contractor. I worked for the same contractor in the office estimating and project managing commercial project for 10 years. I left the construction side of roofing and now work as a roof consultant, which I have been doing for 8-years.

RCI, Inc.

I am a Registered Roof Consultant (RRC) and a Registered Roof Observer (RRO) through RCI, Inc. RCI is a international group of building envelope professionals. I am an approved instructor for RCI educational programs.

Past/Present Clients
We have worked with many local school districts, insurance companies, HOA's, building management companies, and we have a national client with buildings located throughout the US.

©2017 All rights reserved.