You are here:

Silver and Flatware/Wm A Rogers by Oneida Flatware sets

Advertisement


Question
Set 1
Set 1  

Set 2
Set 2  
I have two WmARogers flatware sets.. They are both service for 8 and are in the cases...I would like confirm the pattern names, what year were they made and what is their value?  One set is wm a Rogers silver overlaid...the pattern name may be Chalice, Harmony or Jasmine and may have been produced in 1958...it is in very good condition.  The second set is wm a rogers extra plate...patern may be magnolia (it's the one with the flower pattern in the photos...I have no idea on the year...it is tarnished but is in good condition in the case also.  I would like any info you can give me on these.  Is it okay to clean these? will it Chang the value?   Thank you!

Answer
Hello.

As you have seen, the Wm. A. Rogers brand was taken over by Oneida in the early twentieth century. The pattern you have was known by all three names. It could be that they were introduced at various times under other brands. Also take note that some of the names could also have been used for other patterns. As companies were bought and sold, this happened. The pattern appears to have been introduced in 1958 but under which name I do not know and for how many years it was manufactured I do not know. Unfortunately, used silver plate flatware does not hold its value very well. Sold as a set by an individual, this set probably would bring around one dollar per piece, perhaps a bit more for serving pieces. It's interesting to note that a higher total value might be achieved by selling a few pieces at a time. If you look at actual sales on eBay, you'll see that when there is a sale of two or three pieces at a time, the per-piece price is often higher. This is because you open up the market to buyers looking to add a few pieces to an existing set. Compare the per-piece prices in these two recent sales: http://www.ebay.com/itm/Oneida-CHALICE-HARMONY-5pc-place-setting-VG-EUC-Forks-Sp and http://www.ebay.com/itm/WM-A-ROGERS-CHALICE-PATTERN-68-PC-SILVERPLATE-FLATWARE-S .

It appears that the second set is the Magnolia pattern from Wm. Rogers which was a different company from Wm. A. Rogers. International Silver Company took over the Wm. Rogers brand in 1898. They continued to use the brand and introduced Magnolia in 1951. I do not know how long it was an active pattern. It has roughly the same value as the other set we discussed.

Cleaning with a mild silver polish is good. For these sets, it will not reduce the value and it might increase the value a bit. Do not use a chemical dip cleaner.  

Silver and Flatware

All Answers


Answers by Expert:


Ask Experts

Volunteer


Jim Stringer

Expertise

I answer questions about sterling flatware and other sterling pieces........... I answer value questions at http://whatisitworth.lovetoknow.com/questions/categories/silver. I also author a blog at http://www.SilverChatter.com and write articles about silver at http://www.examiner.com/sterling-silver-in-national/jim-stringer ........... Thanks to nominations from questioners, I'm listed in the Top 50 Experts for 2014 and 2015.......... NOTE: Please do not give me a verbal description of a pattern and ask me to identify it. Attach a picture if you need such help..........

Experience

Buyer and seller of sterling pieces for over ten years. Author of the blog, www.SilverChatter.com. Sterling silver writer for www.Examiner.com.

Publications
Examiner.com; SilverChatter.com; "Selling_Your_Silver: A Guide to Finding a Buyer and Getting a Good Price (www.lulu.com/spotlight/georgiasilver)

Education/Credentials
BS, University of Alabama; MS, University of Maryland

©2016 About.com. All rights reserved.