U.S. History/USA vs Mexico


Was the war the US had with Mexico in 1846 justified

Hi Riley,

This is a matter of opinion. But here are the choices: If you think that the United States had the right to go to war with Mexico in order to expand American territory at the expense of Mexico, then you could say that the war was justified.

If, however, you believe that no country is justified in starting a war just to conquer territory, and that peace is more important than who owns the land, then the war was not justified.

The historical record is clear that the United States provoked war with Mexico for the sole purpose of defeating Mexico, and then acquiring Mexican territory for incorporation into the US. In my own opinion, I don't think the war was justified.

I hope this helps!

- Marc

U.S. History

All Answers

Answers by Expert:

Ask Experts


Marc Aperio


I'm able to answer most questions about US History, whether related to political, social, economic, or military issues.


I've studied American history for nearly 20 years. I'm currently volunteering for AllExperts in Medieval and European history.

My newest book WE NEED TO TALK: 27 DIALOGUES ON RACE IN AMERICA is available in the Amazon Kindle store. http://www.amazon.com/dp/B01E69CUUI Also the author of AMERICAN REVOLUTION 2016: RATIONALE AND AIMS FOR RADICAL CHANGE http://www.amazon.com/American-Revolution-2016-Rationale-Radical-ebook/dp/B00MI9H9VE

BA History (High Honors)

©2016 About.com. All rights reserved.