AboutDavid Expertise I mainly aim to answer questions about playing techniques--intonation,
vibrato, bowing etc. I am somewhat familiar with Baroque and Classical music, though not as much with Romantic. I am unable to answer questions about advanced music theory, violin crafters/brands or the monetary value of a violin.
Experience I have played the violin about nine discontinuous years. Most of my work has been orchestral, with some soloing throughout. I was principal 2nd violinist of the Disney Honors Orchestra in 1998, a six-time All-State Orchestra violinist, a two-time assistant concertmaster and two-time concertmaster of my All-County Orchestra. I also have perfect pitch, which I believe can be learned (though I do not claim to know how to teach it).
Since starting medical school in 2004, I have had fewer chances to play, but I hope to someday resume on a regular basis.
Question Hello,
I am wondering if using the arm vibrato would be better in the long run? My teacher says that the wrist vibrato would give me such problems in my arm as carpal tunnel and arthritis. I would like to be able to also keep my violin arm as long in life as possible! She said that she can teach me whichever I feel comfortable learning. Because of the information she has given me on the diseases, I am not sure which to choose!
Any information would be appreciated!
Nathan
Answer Hi Nathan,
That's an interesting question. As a violinist with a family history of joint problems I can certainly sympathize. However, I am confident that if done correctly, the wrist vibrato should not significantly increase your risk of the health problems you mentioned. I can also say that, having observed many musicians at all levels, the arm vibrato is not used frequently and is generally reserved for 1)portions of music where a very powerful vibrato may be warranted (rare), and 2)musicians who have not (yet) developed the proper flexibility of their wrists. The wrist vibrato is by far the most common type of vibrato, and in my assessment the most useful. Thus I highly recommend that you master it before trying to learn either the arm or finger vibrato variants, which are unlikely to be necessary very often at all. I hope this is of some assistance, good luck with your musical endeavors!
Sincerely, David
