Yoga & Tai Chi/Difference

Advertisement


Question
What is the difference between all these terms and Yoga.
Tai chi chuan,  chi kung , nei gong.

Answer
I will not try to give you a textbook explanation, but more of a real-world explanation.  Yoga is relatively static:  you hold a posture, and try to relax, while performing deep breathing.  It has internal benefits and will also improve muscle tone and cardio vascular fitness, if you do the breathing.  Yoga is of Indian culture with strong roots in Buddhism and (I think) Hinduism.

Tai chi chuan (taijiquan), chi kung (qigong), and nei gong are all Chinese/Taoist in origin.  All are internal arts.  Tai Chi Chuan is an internal martial art; it has all of the benefits of a martial art, and is externally quite dynamic, but the power comes from within, not from brute strength.  There are five major Tai Chi systems (Yang, Chen, Sun, Wu, Wu-Hao) and many minor ones.  All the major systems are related by lineage.

Chi Kung is purely a health-oriented practice that ties our internal energy with our limbs, internal organs, and emotions in order to cleanse, purify, and strengthen our chi.  Since it is based on external exercises, it is correct to say that Tai Chi is also a form of of Chi Kung, but not vice-versa; that is, Tai Chi can be done for health only, but Chi Kung is never a martial art.  There are thousands of possible chi kung exercises:  some are quite specific to fixing a health problem, others are more general for maintenance.

Finally, nei gong is like chi kung only without the external movements:  it is entirely internal.  You could call it meditation, but it is much more active than, say, Zen meditation.  It involves using our mind to move the our breath energy (chi, or qi) through the major meridians of the body.  The goal is to make the qi movement strong and continuous.  In later stages, you learn much more esoteric practices that give you surprising abilities, but if you want to know what they are, you'll have to train with someone for a few years, possibly more, before they will share that information; not so much because it is secret, but because you will not believe it until you can do it yourself.

I hope this helps.  All the arts you asked about can and are practiced for health and retaining youthful vitality, as the goal of Taoism is immortality.  If you have further questions, feel free to ask.

Yours in the Tao,
Dale Napier
www.ElementalTaiChi.com

Yoga & Tai Chi

All Answers


Answers by Expert:


Ask Experts

Volunteer


Dale Napier

Expertise

Tai chi chuan (taijiquan), chi kung (qigong), internal alchemy (nei gong).

Experience

Practicing tai chi since 1977, teaching since 1998; chi kung and internal alchemy, training since 1995, teaching since 1998.

Organizations
Vice President of American Yangjia Michuan Taijiquan Association.

Publications
New book - Tai Chi In Your Life: 8 Principles That Can Change Your Life While Learning and Growing with Tai Chi. Articles - Kung Fu Magazine, Journal of Asian Martial Arts, Journal of American Yangjia Michuan Taijiquan Association

Education/Credentials
Primary teachers: Certification by George Ling Hu (Yangjia Michuan Taijiquan, taught by Wang Yen-nien). Jampa Mackenzie Stewart (chi kung, internal alchemy, senior instructor for Mantak Chia). Other teachers with less exposure: Jeff Bolt (Northern Shaolin Kung Fu), Dr. Yang Jwing-Ming (Chi Kung), Master Wang Yen-nien (internal alchemy), Raul Shelton (Shorin-Ryu karate), Dr. Glenn Morris (Bujinkan ninjutsu and budo). Lesser training in judo and taekwondo.

Awards and Honors
Gold and silver medals in various tai chi competitions (forms, pushing hands).

Past/Present Clients
Currently teaching at the Houston Arboretum and Nature Center; formerly taught at the University of Houston-Downtown.

©2012 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company. All rights reserved.